73 Would You Rather Questions For Music Class

Music class is a fantastic place to explore sounds, rhythms, and melodies. Sometimes, the best way to get students thinking and talking about music is through a fun and engaging activity. That's where Would You Rather Questions For Music Class come in! These clever prompts can spark lively discussions, encourage creative thinking, and help everyone dive deeper into their musical understanding.

What Are Would You Rather Questions For Music Class?

So, what exactly are Would You Rather Questions For Music Class? Simply put, they are questions that present two equally appealing, or sometimes equally challenging, musical scenarios, and students have to choose one. They're not just about picking a favorite song; they're designed to make you think about the 'why' behind your musical preferences and to consider different aspects of music. For instance, would you rather always sing perfectly off-key or always play an instrument perfectly out of tune? These kinds of questions can be silly, thought-provoking, or even a little bit controversial, making them incredibly engaging for students of all ages. The goal is to get them to articulate their reasoning, which is a crucial skill in any subject, especially music.

These questions are so popular because they tap into our natural inclination to make choices and justify them. They create a low-stakes environment for students to express their opinions and engage with musical concepts in a personal way. Imagine a classroom buzzing with debates over whether it's better to have an incredible sense of rhythm but no sense of pitch, or an amazing singing voice but no ability to keep a beat. This kind of interaction fosters a deeper connection with the material. Here's why they work so well:

They encourage active participation.
They promote critical thinking about musical elements.
They can reveal diverse perspectives within the class.
They are a fun and memorable way to learn.
The importance of these questions lies in their ability to make abstract musical concepts relatable and personal, transforming passive learning into an active, enjoyable experience.

Teachers use Would You Rather Questions For Music Class in a variety of ways to enhance learning. They can be used as icebreakers at the beginning of a lesson to get students warmed up, as discussion starters to explore a specific musical topic, or even as exit tickets to gauge understanding. Sometimes, a simple question can lead to a surprisingly complex musical analysis. For example, asking students to choose between composing a symphony that everyone hates or a jingle that everyone loves might lead to discussions about artistic integrity versus popular appeal. Here are some ways they can be implemented:

As a warm-up activity.
To introduce a new topic.
During group discussions.
For quick checks of understanding.
As creative writing prompts.

Would You Rather: Instruments

Would you rather be able to play every instrument perfectly but only for one minute at a time, or be able to play one instrument incredibly well but only by ear?
Would you rather have a violin that always sounds like a kazoo, or a tuba that always sounds like a squeaky toy?
Would you rather be able to play the drums with incredible speed but no timing, or have perfect timing but only be able to play one beat?
Would you rather have a piano with only black keys, or a piano with only white keys?
Would you rather be able to play the guitar with your feet, or play the trumpet with your nose?
Would you rather have a ukulele that only plays one note, or a grand piano that only plays one chord?
Would you rather be able to play any instrument, but only when you're upside down, or play one instrument perfectly, but only when you're asleep?
Would you rather have a drum set that only makes fart noises, or a flute that only makes meowing noises?
Would you rather be able to play the saxophone backwards, or play the clarinet forwards but only when you're hopping on one foot?
Would you rather have a banjo that plays itself but only plays country music, or a synthesizer that you can control but only makes alien noises?
Would you rather be able to perfectly mimic any instrument sound with your voice, or have an instrument that can perfectly mimic your voice?
Would you rather have a harp that only plays discordant notes, or a xylophone that only plays one long, drawn-out note?
Would you rather be able to play the accordion but only in polka music, or play the bagpipes but only in spooky music?
Would you rather have a keyboard that spells out words instead of notes, or a guitar that only plays power chords?
Would you rather be able to play the slide whistle perfectly, or the theremin but only when you're laughing?
Would you rather have a sitar that only plays one string, or a sitar that plays all its strings but only plays silence?
Would you rather be able to play the steel guitar with your teeth, or the harmonica with your elbows?
Would you rather have a recorder that only plays the same three notes, or a triangle that can play any note but only when you're sad?
Would you rather be able to play the banjo but only while juggling, or play the mandolin but only while doing a handstand?
Would you rather have a bass guitar that plays the melody and a guitar that plays the bassline, or a drum set that sings and a singer that plays the drums?

Would You Rather: Singing & Vocals

Would you rather have a voice that sounds like a robot but can hit any note, or a beautiful singing voice but can only sing one note?
Would you rather be able to sing any song perfectly in a language you don't understand, or sing badly in your native language but understand all the lyrics?
Would you rather have your singing voice make everyone in the room instantly happy, or have your singing voice make everyone in the room instantly sad?
Would you rather be able to sing a duet with your favorite artist, but you have to sing their part, or have your favorite artist sing a duet with you, but they have to sing your part?
Would you rather have a voice that can shatter glass, or a voice that can lull any baby to sleep?
Would you rather only be able to sing in opera style, or only be able to rap, even in casual conversation?
Would you rather have a voice that can mimic any animal sound, or a voice that can perfectly imitate any famous singer?
Would you rather be able to sing a song, but you forget the lyrics halfway through, or remember all the lyrics but forget the melody?
Would you rather have your voice always sound like you're gargling, or always sound like you have a stuffy nose?
Would you rather be able to sing a song that everyone remembers forever, but you yourself forget it the moment you finish, or sing a song that only you remember?
Would you rather have a voice that is incredibly loud but always off-key, or a very soft voice that is perfectly in tune?
Would you rather be able to sing like a choir of angels, but only when you're alone, or sing like a dying crow, but everyone loves it?
Would you rather have a voice that can hit incredibly high notes but sounds like a squeaky door, or low notes that sound like a rumbling earthquake?
Would you rather have to sing everything you say, or have to speak everything you sing?
Would you rather be able to sing any song, but you have to do it while doing a silly dance, or sing one song perfectly but you can never sing it again?
Would you rather have a voice that sounds like a chipmunk all the time, or a voice that sounds like a monster all the time?
Would you rather be able to sing any song in reverse, or have to sing every song backwards?
Would you rather have a voice that makes people cry tears of joy, or a voice that makes people cry tears of laughter?
Would you rather be able to sing in perfect harmony with yourself, or sing a duet with someone whose voice clashes horribly with yours?
Would you rather have your singing voice be the most popular ringtone in the world, or be able to communicate with animals through your singing?

Would You Rather: Music Genres

Would you rather only be able to listen to classical music for the rest of your life, or only be able to listen to death metal for the rest of your life?
Would you rather be forced to dance to polka music for an hour every day, or be forced to listen to elevator music for an hour every day?
Would you rather write a hit song in the genre of country, or a revolutionary symphony in the genre of experimental electronic?
Would you rather have to attend a jazz festival where everyone only plays free improvisation, or a folk festival where everyone only sings sea shanties?
Would you rather be able to compose the most beautiful opera, but only be able to hear it in your head, or hear the most annoying jingle ever created, but you can't get it out of your head?
Would you rather have to listen to your least favorite genre of music for an hour every day, or have to play your least favorite instrument for an hour every day?
Would you rather discover a completely new genre of music that no one understands, or become the undisputed king of a very obscure existing genre?
Would you rather have to dance to every song in the style of a robot, or have to sing every song in the style of a cowboy?
Would you rather be able to create the perfect hip-hop beat, but have no lyrical ability, or write amazing lyrics, but have no ability to create beats?
Would you rather attend a concert where the band plays incredibly fast but all the notes are wrong, or incredibly slow but all the notes are perfect?
Would you rather be able to play the blues but only when you're happy, or play the reggae but only when you're stressed?
Would you rather have to listen to a song on repeat for 24 hours that you absolutely love, or a song you hate but it changes every hour?
Would you rather discover a forgotten genre of music that was incredibly popular in ancient times, or invent a genre of music for aliens?
Would you rather have to sing a lullaby at the top of your lungs in a crowded library, or whisper a death metal song in a silent church?
Would you rather be able to perfectly replicate any pop song, but it always sounds slightly off, or create a completely original song that is universally disliked?
Would you rather have to dance like a ballerina to every rock song, or headbang like a metal fan to every classical piece?
Would you rather be able to play any song in the style of a marching band, or play any song in the style of a lullaby?
Would you rather have to listen to only jingles from commercials for a month, or only songs about different types of food?
Would you rather create a rap song that is incredibly popular but has nonsensical lyrics, or a thoughtful poem that no one ever hears?
Would you rather attend a concert where the band only plays one song for three hours, or a concert where the band plays a thousand songs but each is only ten seconds long?

Would You Rather: Music Theory & Concepts

Would you rather have perfect pitch but no sense of rhythm, or perfect rhythm but no sense of pitch?
Would you rather be able to hear all the notes in a chord simultaneously but never distinguish them individually, or be able to distinguish every note but only one at a time?
Would you rather understand all music theory but be unable to create music, or be able to create music but have no understanding of theory?
Would you rather have the ability to instantly transpose any song into any key, but always get the tempo wrong, or have perfect tempo control but always transpose incorrectly?
Would you rather be able to hear silence as music, or hear all music as silence?
Would you rather have a perfect understanding of harmony but struggle with melody, or have a brilliant melodic sense but be lost in harmony?
Would you rather be able to control the dynamics of any piece of music by just thinking it, but you can only think in loud noises, or be able to control the tempo with your mind, but you can only think in slow motion?
Would you rather have a perfect sense of musical form but be unable to recognize different instruments, or recognize every instrument but be confused by musical structure?
Would you rather be able to hear the emotional intent behind every note, but not the note itself, or hear the note perfectly, but have no idea what it's supposed to convey?
Would you rather have a metronome inside your head that you can't turn off, or have a constant echo of every sound you make?
Would you rather be able to predict the next note in any melody with 100% accuracy, but never enjoy listening to it, or be surprised by every note but find every melody enchanting?
Would you rather have to explain musical concepts using only hand gestures, or only using grunts and groans?
Would you rather be able to understand the physics of sound perfectly but not hear it, or hear music perfectly but have no idea how it's made?
Would you rather have your brain process music in slow motion, so you can analyze every detail, or in fast forward, so you experience the whole song at once?
Would you rather be able to hear the underlying rhythm of any situation, like a heartbeat or a traffic pattern, or be able to hear the harmonic content of any color?
Would you rather be able to perfectly deconstruct any musical piece into its individual components, but never be able to put it back together, or be able to build complex musical structures but never understand how they work?
Would you rather have your brain play a different song for every emotion you feel, or have every song you hear trigger a different emotion?
Would you rather be able to hear the "true" sound of an instrument, stripped of all its usual qualities, or have every instrument sound like your own voice?
Would you rather be able to control the reverb of any sound in real-time, but you can only make it sound like you're in a cave, or control the delay, but it always sounds like a military march?
Would you rather have a perfect understanding of a musical concept but be unable to explain it, or be able to explain it perfectly but never truly grasp it?

Would You Rather: Music Performance & Creation

Would you rather perform a song perfectly in front of a huge audience, but have everyone throw rotten tomatoes at you afterward, or perform a song terribly in front of a small audience, but they all give you a standing ovation?
Would you rather compose a piece of music that becomes incredibly famous but you receive no credit, or have a minor hit song that everyone knows you wrote?
Would you rather be able to play any song flawlessly on any instrument, but only when you're the only one listening, or play any song with mistakes but have a massive crowd cheering you on?
Would you rather have your music be played by every radio station in the world, but it’s always slightly out of tune, or have your music played by only one obscure station, but it’s perfect?
Would you rather be able to create the most beautiful melody but have no idea how to arrange it, or be a master arranger but have no melodic ideas?
Would you rather have to perform a concert where you can only play songs from your least favorite artist, or have to compose a symphony based on your favorite food?
Would you rather be able to play every song with incredible passion but constantly make mistakes, or play every song perfectly but with absolutely no emotion?
Would you rather have your music make people dance uncontrollably, or make people think deeply?
Would you rather be a world-famous composer who is never heard, or an unknown musician whose music everyone loves?
Would you rather have to perform a solo piece where you can only use your elbows, or perform a piece with a band where everyone else is playing completely different songs?
Would you rather be able to improvise solos that blow everyone away, but only on instruments you can't play, or play instruments you can play perfectly, but only the same three notes?
Would you rather have your music be used in every movie soundtrack, but always in the sad scenes, or be the background music for every video game, but always in the boss battles?
Would you rather have to sing a lullaby for a crowd of hardened bikers, or perform a death metal anthem at a kindergarten talent show?
Would you rather be able to perfectly mimic the sound of any instrument, but only when you're imitating a duck, or be able to play any instrument, but only when you're balancing on a unicycle?
Would you rather have your music instantly make people happy, but they forget it the moment it stops, or make people feel a profound emotion, but they never understand why?
Would you rather be able to compose a song that makes a whole stadium sing along, but you forget the song the moment you finish, or compose a song that only one person hears and loves?
Would you rather have to perform every song with a different, ridiculous costume, or have to perform every song while wearing a sign that describes your biggest musical flaw?
Would you rather be able to create a musical masterpiece that only you can hear, or create a terrible noise that everyone else can hear?
Would you rather have your music be the soundtrack to every major historical event, but always be the wrong mood, or have your music be the soundtrack to every mundane task, like brushing your teeth?
Would you rather be able to jam with legendary musicians from the past, but you can only play the triangle, or have a solo career playing your favorite instrument, but only to an audience of mannequins?

Would You Rather: Music Technology & Sound

Would you rather have a microphone that only picks up whispers, or speakers that only play at maximum volume?
Would you rather be able to control the effects on any song, but you can only use the "robot voice" effect, or be able to use any effect, but you can only apply it to your own voice?
Would you rather have a music player that only plays songs you hate, or a music player that only plays songs you've never heard before?
Would you rather be able to create the perfect sound effects for any movie, but they all sound like a cat meowing, or be able to compose a soundtrack that perfectly matches the mood, but it’s always slightly out of sync?
Would you rather have a studio where every instrument sounds like it's underwater, or a studio where every sound is perfectly clear but incredibly boring?
Would you rather be able to record your music perfectly, but it always sounds like it was recorded in a tin can, or record your music with lots of background noise, but it sounds incredibly rich and warm?
Would you rather have a synthesizer that can create any sound imaginable, but it only responds to interpretive dance, or a sampler that can perfectly loop any sound, but it only loops the sound of someone snoring?
Would you rather be able to control the pitch of any sound, but you can only raise it, or control the volume, but you can only make it quieter?
Would you rather have a music streaming service that only recommends songs you absolutely despise, or a music streaming service that only plays songs from 1950?
Would you rather be able to autotune your voice perfectly, but it makes you sound like a chipmunk, or have a natural singing voice, but it always sounds like you're about to cry?
Would you rather have a digital audio workstation that has infinite tracks but only one sound, or one track but infinite sounds?
Would you rather be able to create complex electronic music, but only using a children's toy keyboard, or play any acoustic instrument perfectly, but only through a broken amplifier?
Would you rather have a soundboard that plays random noises every time you press a button, or a metronome that randomly changes tempo and volume?
Would you rather be able to hear the "digital footprint" of every song, like a hidden layer of data, or be able to hear the "analog warmth" of every digital song?
Would you rather have a music app that automatically generates a song based on your current mood, but it's always the wrong mood, or generates a song based on the weather, but it's always the wrong weather?
Would you rather be able to create surround sound experiences, but they only consist of one repeating sound, or create mono sound experiences that are incredibly complex and layered?
Would you rather have a vocoder that can make you sound like any celebrity, but it only works when you're singing about vegetables, or a vocoder that can make you sound like any instrument, but it only works when you're speaking?
Would you rather have a music editing software that has every feature imaginable, but the interface is designed for aliens, or a simple interface, but it can only do one thing: add a cowbell?
Would you rather be able to record any sound in the world, but it always comes out sounding like a rubber chicken, or be able to play any instrument perfectly, but only when you're surrounded by rubber chickens?
Would you rather have a music player that shows you the emotional journey of every song, but you can't hear the music, or hear the music perfectly, but you have no idea what the emotions are?

Would You Rather Questions For Music Class are more than just a fun game; they're a powerful tool for learning and engagement. By presenting students with these interesting dilemmas, educators can unlock deeper thinking, foster lively discussions, and make the world of music even more exciting and understandable. So, the next time you're in music class, be prepared to make a choice – it might just lead to a musical revelation!