73 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers

Ever found yourself in a situation where you had to make a tough choice, and you wished someone had presented you with two equally interesting, albeit crazy, options? That's exactly what "Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers" are all about! They're not just for fun; these questions can be a surprisingly effective tool to get teachers thinking, laughing, and maybe even connecting on a deeper level.

What Are "Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers" and Why Do They Rock?

Imagine being in a classroom, or maybe during a staff meeting, and someone throws out a question like: "Would you rather have all your students speak in riddles or all your students communicate solely through interpretive dance?" That's a classic "Would You Rather" scenario. These questions present two equally challenging, humorous, or thought-provoking situations, forcing you to pick one. They're super popular because they're simple, engaging, and can lead to hilarious discussions. Plus, they're a fantastic way to break the ice or inject some fun into otherwise routine situations. The importance of these questions lies in their ability to spark creativity, encourage critical thinking, and foster a sense of community by revealing shared perspectives or humorous reactions.

So, how are they used? Well, teachers might use them:

• As a warm-up activity at the beginning of a class or a meeting.
• To encourage creative writing prompts.
• To facilitate discussions about ethics or problem-solving in a low-stakes environment.
• During team-building exercises among staff.
• Simply as a way to lighten the mood and share a laugh.

It’s all about making people think outside the box. Sometimes, the "right" answer isn't obvious, and that's what makes them so interesting. It's less about finding the perfect solution and more about the journey of deciding.

Classroom Management Dilemmas

Would you rather:

1. Have students who are perfectly silent but never learn, or students who are incredibly engaged but constantly disruptive?
2. Have to give every student a perfect score on every assignment, or have to grade every assignment with extreme harshness?
3. Have students who only ask questions you already know the answer to, or students who ask questions that completely stump you?
4. Be able to magically make students disappear for a day, or have them magically appear with homework already completed?
5. Have a classroom where every student agrees with everything you say, or a classroom where every student respectfully challenges your ideas?
6. Have to explain every single concept in extreme detail, or have to explain everything in super brief, cryptic hints?
7. Deal with one student who talks non-stop, or a group of three students who constantly whisper and pass notes?
8. Have students who come to class unprepared but willing to try, or students who come prepared but completely unmotivated?
9. Be able to read students' minds about their understanding, or have students be able to read your mind about your grading criteria?
10. Have to deal with an endless stream of excuses for late homework, or have to deal with students who are always late to class?
11. Have every student suddenly develop a photographic memory for facts, but forget how to think critically, or have every student be a critical thinker but have terrible recall?
12. Have to re-teach the same lesson every single day, or have to teach a new, complex topic every single day?
13. Have students who are afraid to speak up, or students who speak up without thinking?
14. Be able to instantly calm a chaotic classroom with a single word, or have a superpower that makes students instantly remember everything you teach?
15. Have students who only do the bare minimum, or students who overachieve to the point of being annoying?
16. Have to listen to the same pop song on repeat all day, or have to have a student hum loudly for the entire class period?
17. Have students who are always asking "Why?", or students who never ask "Why?"?
18. Have to give every student a gold star for attendance, or have to give every student a detention for tardiness?
19. Have students who are incredibly polite but never participate, or students who are rude but always have insightful contributions?
20. Have to wear a ridiculous costume every day, or have your students have to wear uniforms that you choose?

School System Shenanigans

Would you rather:

1. Have your school day be an hour longer but all breaks are doubled, or have your school day be an hour shorter but all breaks are halved?
2. Have unlimited access to coffee and snacks in the staff room, or have unlimited access to professional development workshops that you actually enjoy?
3. Have all your students excel in their favorite subject but struggle in all others, or have all your students be average in all subjects?
4. Have to eat lunch with the students every day, or have to attend every single school event, no matter how boring?
5. Have your school's internet be lightning fast but never be able to print, or have your school's internet be incredibly slow but have a magically refilling printer ink supply?
6. Have every parent-teacher conference be a 5-minute friendly chat, or have every parent-teacher conference be a 30-minute debate?
7. Have your school be famous for its amazing sports team but terrible academics, or famous for its brilliant academics but terrible sports teams?
8. Have to grade all your papers by hand with a quill pen, or have to use a computer that only types in Comic Sans?
9. Have your school have a vending machine that dispenses lesson plans, or a vending machine that dispenses perfectly graded essays?
10. Have to dress like a historical figure every Friday, or have to speak in a different accent every Monday?
11. Have your school be located in a tropical paradise but have no resources, or have your school be in a barren wasteland but have every resource imaginable?
12. Have to answer every email within 5 minutes, or have to attend every optional meeting?
13. Have your school have a mandatory talent show every month, or a mandatory interpretive dance session every week?
14. Have to create all your own textbooks from scratch, or have to use textbooks that are 50 years out of date?
15. Have your school have a petting zoo instead of a library, or have your school have a silent retreat center instead of a cafeteria?
16. Have to give up your lunch break or your planning period?
17. Have to communicate with parents solely through carrier pigeon, or solely through interpretive dance?
18. Have to teach a subject you dislike intensely for the rest of your career, or have to teach your favorite subject but only to students who despise it?
19. Have your school run entirely on student-generated music, or student-generated art?
20. Have to judge every school competition, or have to participate in every school competition?
21. Have to wear a bell around your neck that rings every time you speak, or have to have a puppet that speaks for you?

Subject-Specific Struggles

Would you rather:

1. (Math) Have students who can solve complex equations in their heads but can't do basic arithmetic, or students who excel at arithmetic but freeze at algebra?
2. (Science) Have students who are brilliant at memorizing scientific facts but have no idea how to conduct an experiment, or students who are amazing at experiments but can't recall a single fact?
3. (English) Have students who write eloquent essays but can't speak in complete sentences, or students who are fluent speakers but their writing is incomprehensible?
4. (History) Have students who can perfectly recite every date and event but don't understand the "why," or students who grasp the historical context but forget all the names and dates?
5. (Art) Have students who can perfectly replicate famous artworks but have no original ideas, or students who have wild, original ideas but lack any technical skill?
6. (Music) Have students who can play any instrument flawlessly but can't read music, or students who can read music perfectly but are tone-deaf?
7. (PE) Have students who are incredibly athletic but refuse to work in teams, or students who are great team players but struggle with basic coordination?
8. (Foreign Language) Have students who can speak fluently but have terrible grammar, or students who have perfect grammar but a very limited vocabulary?
9. (Computer Science) Have students who can hack into any system but can't write a basic program, or students who can write complex programs but can't connect to the internet?
10. (Biology) Have students who can dissect any organism perfectly but are grossed out by anything living, or students who love all living things but can't stand the sight of a scalpel?
11. (Physics) Have students who can calculate gravitational pull but think the Earth is flat, or students who understand complex theories but believe in perpetual motion machines?
12. (Chemistry) Have students who can mix chemicals flawlessly but have no idea what they're doing, or students who understand all the reactions but are terrified of anything that bubbles?
13. (Geography) Have students who can name every capital city but can't read a map, or students who can navigate any terrain but don't know where they are?
14. (Economics) Have students who can predict market crashes but can't manage their allowance, or students who are great savers but have no understanding of the broader economy?
15. (Sociology) Have students who can analyze group behavior but have no social skills themselves, or students who are incredibly popular but can't explain why?
16. (Psychology) Have students who can diagnose any mental condition but are constantly anxious themselves, or students who are incredibly calm but have no interest in understanding others?
17. (Literature) Have students who can write incredibly complex literary analyses but don't enjoy reading, or students who devour books but struggle to articulate their thoughts?
18. (Drama) Have students who can improvise brilliantly but freeze on a script, or students who can recite lines perfectly but lack any spontaneity?
19. (Philosophy) Have students who can debate abstract concepts endlessly but can't make a simple decision, or students who make quick decisions but can't explain their reasoning?
20. (Health) Have students who know all the medical facts but have terrible personal health habits, or students who are very healthy but have no idea why?

Teacher's Lounge Conundrums

Would you rather:

1. Have your coffee machine break down every single morning, or have your comfortable staff room chair spontaneously combust once a week?
2. Have to grade papers while listening to polka music on repeat, or have to attend mandatory "team-building" trust falls every Friday?
3. Have every student in your class mysteriously swap lunches with each other daily, or have every teacher in the school swap lesson plans randomly each morning?
4. Be able to talk to animals but they only complain about school, or be able to understand what students are thinking but they only think about snacks?
5. Have your only form of communication with colleagues be through interpretive dance, or have to communicate exclusively through handwritten notes delivered by a student messenger?
6. Have to solve all your problems with a magic eight ball, or have to solve all your problems by flipping a coin?
7. Have your entire grade book turn into a giant crossword puzzle, or have your whiteboard turn into a giant etch-a-sketch that you can't erase?
8. Have to substitute teach for every subject you're unqualified for, or have to be the school principal for a day?
9. Have a personal assistant who is incredibly skilled but only speaks in rhymes, or have a personal assistant who is completely incompetent but incredibly enthusiastic?
10. Have to wear a sign that says "Ask Me Anything About This Subject" at all times, or have to wear a hat that randomly plays silly sound effects?
11. Have your school be overrun by friendly but demanding squirrels, or have your school be haunted by the ghost of a grumpy former librarian?
12. Have to participate in a school-wide scavenger hunt every week, or have to write a haiku about your day every day?
13. Have your printer only print pictures of cats, or have your projector only show silent films?
14. Have to sing your lesson plans, or have to act out all your explanations?
15. Have your colleagues constantly ask you for the answers to their own subject's homework, or have your students constantly ask you for advice on their dating lives?
16. Have to wear mismatched shoes every day, or have to wear a different silly hat every day?
17. Have your grading system be entirely based on student drawings, or entirely based on student poems?
18. Have to go back to teaching elementary school for a year, or have to manage the school's social media account for a year?
19. Have your favorite snack magically appear every time you answer a question correctly, or have a perfectly brewed cup of your favorite drink appear every time you finish grading a stack of papers?
20. Have to live in the school overnight once a month, or have to eat only cafeteria food for a week every month?

Futuristic Teaching Follies

Would you rather:

1. Have your students learn entirely through virtual reality simulations, but they forget how to interact in the real world, or have them learn entirely through hands-on activities, but they have no access to any technology?
2. Have your students be taught by AI robots that are always polite but never creative, or by alien beings who are brilliant but have incomprehensible teaching methods?
3. Have your classroom be equipped with a "teleporter" that can instantly take students anywhere in the world for field trips, but it sometimes malfunctions and sends them to the wrong century, or have a "time machine" that lets students visit historical events, but they can't interact?
4. Have your students communicate with you through telepathy, but they can only send you images, or have them communicate through song, but the songs are always off-key?
5. Have to teach a class of genetically engineered super-geniuses who are bored by everything, or a class of adorable but incredibly distractible aliens?
6. Have your school be powered by student dreams, but sometimes the dreams are nightmares, or powered by student laughter, but sometimes the laughter is uncontrollable?
7. Have students who can download knowledge directly into their brains, but they lose the ability to feel emotions, or students who have incredibly strong emotions but can barely remember what they learned yesterday?
8. Have to use holographic textbooks that can interact with students, but they glitch and show embarrassing images, or have to use ancient scrolls that are incredibly informative but incredibly fragile?
9. Have your students be able to levitate to their desks, but they constantly float away, or have them be able to teleport to the front of the line, but they always arrive with a loud "POOF!"?
10. Have to teach in a classroom where gravity changes randomly, or in a classroom where the walls constantly shift and change color?
11. Have your students be able to control the weather in the classroom, but they always choose to create a blizzard, or have them be able to control the lighting, but they always set it to disco mode?
12. Have to teach a class where everyone speaks a different invented language, or a class where everyone speaks backwards?
13. Have a classroom where the furniture rearranges itself based on the lesson, but it sometimes rearranges itself into a giant hamster wheel, or a classroom where the whiteboard displays whatever the students are thinking about?
14. Have to give assignments that are completed on Mars, or assignments that are delivered by space dolphins?
15. Have your students be able to see the future, but they can only see embarrassing moments, or have them be able to predict the past, but they can only predict disasters?
16. Have to teach a class where the subject matter changes every hour based on the whims of a mischievous sprite, or a class where the textbook rewrites itself every night with nonsensical information?
17. Have your students wear uniforms that change color based on their mood, or uniforms that emit a faint scent of their favorite food?
18. Have to communicate with your students through a series of complex hand gestures that change daily, or through a secret code that you must invent each week?
19. Have your school be located on the moon, or have your school be located underwater?
20. Have your students be able to absorb information by touching objects, but they also absorb the object's history, or have them be able to communicate with plants, but the plants are always complaining about the soil?

Personal Quirks and Catastrophes

Would you rather:

1. Have every student remember your name but mispronounce it hilariously every single time, or have them remember your name perfectly but always call you by another teacher's name?
2. Have to eat your lunch in complete silence every day, or have to wear a squeaky clown nose during every class?
3. Have your students write you thank-you notes that are incredibly elaborate but completely inaccurate, or have them write you short, blunt notes that are surprisingly insightful?
4. Have to communicate with your family solely through limericks, or have to communicate with your friends solely through dramatic monologues?
5. Have your alarm clock wake you up by singing opera at the top of its lungs, or have your car horn honk the "Happy Birthday" song whenever you press it?
6. Have to give up your favorite snack for a year, or have to listen to your least favorite song on repeat for an entire week?
7. Have your personal library spontaneously burst into flames, or have your entire music collection turn into polka music?
8. Have to wear socks with sandals every single day, or have to wear a fanny pack everywhere you go?
9. Have your entire closet filled with only Hawaiian shirts, or have your entire closet filled with only velvet tracksuits?
10. Have to greet everyone you meet with a dramatic bow, or have to give everyone a high-five every time you see them?
11. Have your phone autocorrect every word to "pickle," or have your phone randomly change the language to Klingon?
12. Have to sneeze uncontrollably whenever you're asked a difficult question, or have to hiccup every time you try to explain something important?
13. Have your shadow come to life and offer unsolicited advice, or have your reflection in mirrors start talking to you?
14. Have to eat all your meals with chopsticks, no matter what you're eating, or have to wear oven mitts on your hands all the time?
15. Have your favorite celebrity show up at your door every morning with a brand new, bizarre hobby, or have your pet suddenly gain the ability to talk but only complain about their food?
16. Have to sing your grocery list, or have to choreograph your commute to work?
17. Have your hair turn a different bright color every day without your control, or have your clothes randomly change patterns throughout the day?
18. Have to replace all your light bulbs with disco balls, or have to replace all your doorknobs with rubber chickens?
19. Have your computer automatically suggest "banana" as the solution to every problem, or have your printer only print pictures of ducks?
20. Have to wear a jester hat every day, or have to speak in a squeaky voice at random intervals?

So, there you have it! "Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers" are more than just silly scenarios. They're a gateway to laughter, critical thinking, and a little bit of insight into the minds of the amazing educators who guide our learning. They prove that even the toughest choices can be made a little more fun, one hypothetical dilemma at a time.